RSS Feed

Mists of Pandaria : Item Squishing – The Great Lootralizer

Interesting topic at the WoW Developer Water Cooler blog feature this week, namely the topic of Item Squishing or Item “Compression”.  The conundrum of it all is pretty simple: Items and stats are growing exponentially fast.  So fast that stats are starting to get a little ridiculous.  Ludicrous, even. Items in the theoretical 5.3 patch will have +thousands to stats and 6.3 would have over tens of thousands.

The bigger picture problem that Blizzard was trying to sell home was that computers will not be able to handle dealing with that many variables when it comes to damage, as tens of thousands of stats on every item logically would equate to doing millions of damage.  That million plus damage is the root problem of this all as the game requires both the servers and your game clients to be precise.  Ten million four hundred thirty-six thousand nine hundred and forty-two, kind of precise.  That is as annoying to read out like that as it is strenuous for a server to process.  Maybe not one player at a time, but imagine Alterac Valley.

That is a LOT of virtual dice to keep rolling every time your DoTs tick.  Something has to change.

The first of several ideas started minor and even comical.  Of these my favorite was simply rounding off damage at “10k” or “2m” instead of thousands and millions, but they displayed it in such a way as to make fun of the people who will inevitably be the largest group of nay-sayers to these proposed ideas.

While that could work, it would only really delay the inevitable.  Later on the honest ideas started rolling out, which is the whole point of this post ^_^  Item Squishing is the act of taking existing items and squishing them down to more manageable levels, and lowering damage output as well.  The developers made it very clear we would still do the same percentage of damage as we do now, only the numbers itself will shrink.

The loudest group against this proposed change is those who claim to only enjoy seeing big numbers when they do damage.  The bigger the number, the better.  While I can understand seeing big numbers is great, it really is secondary to the process.  You don’t care about the number itself, you just care at how BIG the number is compared to normal.  People don’t seem to be grasping that on the forums, though.

Let me give you an opposite example.  Was playing Black Ops with a bud over the weekend and one mode was Team Deathmatch or something similar.  I noticed in this particular mode that every kill the respective team got earned them exactly 100 points.  Not ten, not fifty, but 100.  That changed everything.  The shiny bars at the bottom keeping score surged forward, but for what?  It was first to 2,000 wins, but we were never really playing that game.  We were playing to twenty.  As with the rest of that FPS ‘series’, it was merely over-inflated hype.  I don’t know if anyone playing even noticed, but it certainly rubbed me the wrong way for being misleading.

WoW is trying to avoid getting to that by nipping it here and now.  Damage is related to the content you are in.  It doesn’t matter if you do 20 or 10 million if each hit takes off 10% of the mob’s health bar.  For that reason, I am also in support of the change.  But, I am not so for it that I can’t see potential issues.  If you take a gander at the graph they released, you’ll see the new proposed item levels they sorta have in mind.

The lighter shades above show where we are presently, the darker colors are where they plan to be.  This isn’t 100% going to happen, but come on.  It’s a graph.  This is Science.

My two concerns with this change is, first, Cataclysm still has a huge impact on the item level, or “ilevel”.  Based on the numbers you go from ilevel 75 to 175 from 80 to 85.  .  That’s basically all of 1-60 made up in five levels.  If that math keeps up, we’ll need *another* round of squishing, another Great Lootralizer to even the scales, at the start of the very next expansion after Mists of Pandaria.  (175/75 = 2.3ish.  Cata ends at 175, multiply that by the 2.3 and poof, 402.  Conveniently where Cata is at presently based on that graph.)

Secondly, is that 1-60 content is seemingly not going to change.  If our items at level 85 before getting tier gear are marginally better than tier gear from Classic content… how the heck are we gonna raid outdated stuff solo?  I don’t do this often, but I have helped out friends in the past, and I do like checking out old 5mans for Transmogrification… if our stats get lowered not only will damage we deliver go down, so will the amount we can take.  Add in Warriors and the like blocking percentage damage instead of whole amounts like we did in Wrath, and that makes old content a lot less soloable than now.  There was a post made about this issue on the forums, but avoiding giving direct answers only solidifies the worry some people are having about this.  The Blue in question is Daxxarri, and they said:

It seems to me that some of those that have expressed misgivings about the squish are worried about feeling ‘nerfed’ when facing older content, but the item squish shouldn’t mean that soloing older raid content will die, necessarily. Though we appreciate the feedback, I think it’s safe to say that we wouldn’t want anyone to turn their back on the idea purely out of concern for losing the ability to take down older raids solo or in small groups.


Wudya mean, “shouldn’t mean that soloing older raid content will die, necessarily”?  Is that the PR way of saying ‘You can still do it, stupid.  Just bring 39 others with ya!’?  Ending the comment with “small groups” adds another clue, in my opinion.

Daxx, if you go through with the squish, if everything goes smooth/properly do you guys see it affecting the numbers needed for old BC/WotLK raids etc? If so, how much?

It’s very early days yet, and as Ghostcrawler indicated in the Watercooler, we don’t even know which direction we’d be going in yet (if we end up pulling the trigger on it at all). So, with that in mind, I’m just not in a position to comment on it at the moment, but we are interested in the feedback that we’ve seen, including support for the idea.


In short, ‘Even though you asked be a very obvious question and could say the answer to it right now… I can’t legally.  Sorry.’

This leaves a massive door open for both good and bad comments to be crammed into this posters mouth.  Again, I am for the idea.  But I never think that limiting the player ever ends well, especially after many have grown so accustomed to the idea of running old content solo.

Perhaps add solo dungeons to the list of things to include in PvE Scenarios?  Fast groups with items that look identical to the originals so Transmog Hunters can still have fun with modernized Old Content?

I’m sure we’ll all find out soon enough.  Last I remember that ol’ business conference call with Blizzard stated a Q2 released of Mists of Pandaria.  I dunno if Diablo 3’s delay pushed it back any, but things are definitely on the conveyor belt to launch at this point.  Also, patch 4.3 is starting to appear on the Blizzard (Background) Downloader.  So you know what that means.

Cata is almost over!  It is almost over, friends!

/happily sobbing a la Tom Hanks in Money Pit

After nearly a year of pointless nothingness, we are coming upon a shiny new continent and a new race and class.  We have stared into the xpack and the xpack stared back into us.  Though many have fallen, we the proud remain.

Cata is almost gone, thank the flying spaghetti monster! XD

9 responses »

  1. I lol’d at that pic!

    I really enjoy soloing old content at this point and would hate to see that change. That said, I think this xpac really did a huge job on inflation. Now they want to back up the truck. Why didn’t they think this over to begin with? It’s like running someone over then backing up and saying, ‘Well that wasn’t so smart, lets put him back together!” I mean the damage has been done and you’re still going to piss people off.

    I think Blizzard needs to think things over before doing such dramatic changes on such a constant basis. Heroics are hard…. Heroics are not hard! Over complicating stats, combining stats…. It gets to a point where it feels like we’re dealing with one of those plastic surgery addicts… We never know what things are going to look like after going under the knife so many times. With each patch and expansion I feel like I recognize my characters less and less.

    Anyhow I welcome 4.3, after that I sort of feel uncertain.

    • The only thing that could have topped that undead mage picture was to play a deep rocker voice with echoy vocals every time it is shown.

      The truck analogy is pretty nice XD I think they admitted back in Wrath that they fumbled gear score when they tried out hard modes. Needed a reason to do harder difficulty, so new gear had to be made. Then people complained they wanted more hard modes of every instance and blarrgh. Cata nixed almost all of that, they gutted the system to one raid lockout per week with a really lame reasoning behind it. (So people don’t feel the need ot do both to stay competitive. I don’t see anyone playing at gunpoint. Outside of China, anyway.)

      I agree the back and forth is a bit annoying, but not to be Mr. Everlasting Sunshine on this whole deal, they did have to mention it sometime before it was released. While I’m not 100% happy with the current version they are heavily suggesting, they have admitted several times it is not yet set in stone and appears to be easily changed as well as early in developement. Might not even happen this xpack.

      Either way, I’d run those solo raids and dungeons sooner rather than later XD

  2. Personally I trust Blizzard to sort out what ever they are going to do in MoP, heck in all honesty what can we actually do if they decide to make us all level 1 again. Apart from complain in the forums nothing much else than un-sub.

    The only thing I want right now Is Chaos Orbs to be BoE (which they are becoming in 4.3) and Tier armour from the JP vendor to not require a token from a raid to by the Shoulders and Helm. The rate my two Paladins are going I will have Tier 12 chest, legs and gloves with the rest coming from ZA/ZG before I ever complete a set of armour (which includes set bonuses)

    Thinking about it the other thing I don’t want to see is more Heroic only modes instances. I was chatting to some one the other day and they suggested that the new LFR tool we be the “normals” and the 5 mans will be Heroic only. This makes me sad.

    • Yeah, tokens are a PitA. I think they are giving out a set of 4.3 raid gear entirely for JP and all that, aren’t they? Do we know if it will have the same look as the actual raid gear, for Transmog purposes at least? I think Wrath did the same thing with Icecrown, sharing the same look and all. But it’s been awhile so I forget haha I know the stats, individually, were better on those items but the ‘cost’ was they didn’t have any set bonuses.

      Nah, I think that quote by the devs was botch outta Blizzcon. I think it stated they will not be doing max level non-heroic instances. Meaning, no instances you can only do at max level. There was too small of a niche to matter, so they are making the nine or so they are having at launch going to be probably 88-90 range. Once you ding 90, and have the gear, you can do heroics. They didn’t mean “you can only do these instances as heroics” as many people took it.

  3. I think this is good. It is needed, or at least will be needed in the future.
    Poor servers get enough stress as it is.

    Its kinda like how some people didn’t like cata, but the 1-60 stuff had to be revamped eventually. Now that it is over with, we can get back to focusing on max level content.

    Some people may not like to see the numbers go down, but it is as you described. It all depends on what is normal. In some games a crit of 200 is high and then there are the disgaia games that go up to 100 million.

    And Q2 release of Mists of Pandaria would be nice, but when does D3 come out then?

    • What is interesting is that by updating old world, they can so easily swap in and out new content. One day Gilneas might just exist again, tada! Unlikely soon, but still possible now that they overhauled.

      Yeah, Disgaea is friggin’ nuts on what damage you can do. I still need to uber up my toons though. Only hitting for 1,000 or so on normal attacks. Need MOAR damage! Caster does a couple Ks, and I did enforce a couple laws by force! That was a nice change. Couple 250-500 range mobs back to back at once and I pawned em. Made me feel all nice.

      …and I didn’t need to do a kajillion damage a hit to feel epic neither!

      Q2 was planned prior to the D3 delay, I dunno when it will pan out, but I’ll play both so I’m not gonna sweat it much ^_^

  4. Like you said about inevitability, it was bound to happen! XD

    The hit the nail on the head when it comes to your commentary about the loudest
    group against the proposed change. They’re not really seeing the big picture there, but I get their argument isn’t so much logical as it is emotional. It’s HARD to get over those huge numbers when you’ve been seeing them steadily going up and up and up for years, I’m sure it’s become almost cathartic!

    • I could see that. Bigger and bigger numbers do make a player feel better. Just the other day I finally got colossus smash and for the first time saw a crit over 10k on a non-execute on my warrior. With better gear those numbers will only increase, but I still am able to step away from the situation and appreciate that the big crit numbers will still feel nice when I do them, even if a few zeros are lopped off :P

      Mind you, if we only do 200 crits and still have like 20k health, that would be a bit painful >.> But I’m gonna assume the know how a calculator works hee hee Better yet, make it so roffleganks aren’t so one-sided, and healers are not so endless heal-tanky in pvp. It’s not like they would not see it coming, either. Have a lot of friends who heal and all they do is laugh manically when I complain about healers outhealing groups of 3 or more enemies beating on them.

      Almost makes me want to level up a rogue. Almost.

  5. Pingback: Is WoW heading to its very own NGE? « Screaming monkeys

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

%d bloggers like this: